Is Persil Better Than Tide? Laundry Detergents Compared
Cleaners Talk is reader-supported. This post contains affiliate links, we may earn a commission at no additional costs to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
When it comes to laundry detergent, there are two big names that stand out from the rest: Persil and Tide. Both brands have been around for years and have built up a loyal following of fans.
So, which one is better?
According to USA Today and reviewed.com, Persil removed an average of 2 percent more stains than Tide. While that difference isn't clearly visible to the naked eye, it does make a difference over repeated washings. However, Tide is much more affordable and has more variety to choose from.
In this blog post, we will take a look at the pros and cons of both laundry detergent brands. By comparing Persil vs. Tide, we hope to help you decide which one is right for you!
Persil vs. Tide Comparison
Persil is a popular laundry detergent brand that is known for its high quality and powerful cleaning performance. Tide, on the other hand, is the world’s largest laundry detergent manufacturer and is favored by many for its affordable prices. So, which one should you choose?
Here are some things to consider:
1. Cleaning Performance
Persil is clearly the winner when it comes to cleaning performance. In independent testing, Persil has consistently outperformed Tide in terms of removing stains and dirt from clothing.
If you want your laundry to come out looking its best, then Persil is the way to go.
Now, to be fair, Tide is no slouch when it comes to cleaning performance. It does a good job of removing stains and dirt from clothes. But, if you are looking for the best possible clean, then Persil is your best bet.
2. Odor Removal
Persil is available in various variants like “odor fighter" and "intense fresh". Both these variants are designed to remove odors from clothes, leaving them smelling fresh and clean.
Similarly, Tide also offers an “odor eliminator” variant that is designed to remove unpleasant odors from clothes. However, Persil was found to be more effective at removing odors than Tide as per popular opinion, however marginally. So if odor removal is a priority for you, then Persil is the better option.
3. Effectiveness for Sensitive Skin
Both Persil and Tide are considered to be safe for use on sensitive skin.
However, there have been some reports that Persil can be a little bit harsher on skin than Tide. If you have very sensitive skin, then Tide may be the better option for you.
4. Variants Available
Both Tide and Persil come in a variety of forms, including liquid, powder, and pods.
Liquid is the most common form, as it can be used in both traditional washing machines and high-efficiency washers. Powder is also popular, as it tends to be cheaper than other forms. Pods are newer to the market, but have been growing in popularity due to their convenience.
Tide has a lot more varieties of detergents available for various types of cleaning needs.
They have a different product offering for every need like: Tide pods for laundry, Tide Purclean for eco-friendly washing, Tide boost for extra tough stains. You also get variants for different colors, even brightness.
On the other hand, Persil has only three main types of products- liquid, powder and pods. So, in terms of variants available, Tide is the clear winner because it offers more variety.
5. Scent
Both Tide and Persil offer a variety of scents to choose from. However, some users have reported that the scent of Persil can be a bit overwhelming. If you are looking for a laundry detergent with a strong scent, then Persil is a good option. However, if you prefer a more subtle scent, then Tide may be better for you.
6. Price
Both Tide and Persil are widely available and can be found at most major retailers. In terms of price, Tide is usually the more affordable option. However, the difference is not noteworthy most of the time.
While many consider Persil to be expensive, in our opinion, price is not the deciding factor when it comes to choosing between Tide and Persil. The better option really depends on your specific needs and preferences.
7. Independent Testing Reports: Tide vs Persil
Various noteworthy reviewers like Good Housekeeping, reviewed.com and Consumer Reports have compared the two products across various parameters and have given us some valuable insights.
As per Good Housekeeping, Persil removed more stains than Tide in their testing. They also awarded Tide with the Ultimate Single Dose Laundry Detergent.
Consumer Reports on the other hand recognized Persil's Sensitive formula as the best one for those with sensitive skin. The detergent was able to get rid of stains even without harsh chemicals. They also recognized Persil's cleaning disks for it superior stain removal performance.
Reviewed.com ranked Persil above Tide when it came to overall cleaning performance. They found that Persil was better at removing both dirt and tough stains from clothes.
In general, all these reviewers seem to agree that when it comes down to pure stain removal power, Persil is the clear winner over Tide. However, Tide does have some advantages over Persil as well, like its wide variety of products, affordable price and its recognition by Good Housekeeping.
The Verdict
So, is Persil better than Tide? In our opinion, it depends on your specific needs and preferences. Both detergents are effective at removing stains and odors from clothes.
However, if you are looking for a detergent with a strong scent, then Persil may be the better option for you. If price is a major factor, then Tide is usually the more affordable option. But, if you have sensitive skin, then Persil may be the better choice. Ultimately, the best detergent for you will depend on your specific needs.
Related articles:
Sofia Rodriguez
As a professional house cleaner, I'm passionate about cleanliness. I write this blog to help anyone take better care of their homes and ultimately their loved ones.